An insulation resistance result without its test conditions is not a maintenance record. “IR = 500 MΩ” cannot be trended reliably if the next reader does not know the winding temperature, test voltage, elapsed time, connection or whether cables and accessories were included.
What the two measurements describe
Insulation resistance (IR) is the measured DC resistance between the winding and earth, or between separated winding sections, at a stated time after voltage is applied. The reading is influenced by surface leakage, moisture, contamination, insulation geometry, temperature and the instrument.
Polarization index (PI) compares two timed readings. A common form is:
PI = IR at 10 minutes ÷ IR at 1 minute
A rising resistance during the test can reflect decreasing absorption and polarization current relative to leakage current. The ratio is useful, but it is not a direct measurement of remaining insulation life.
IEC 60034-27-4:2018 provides recommended procedures and minimum acceptable values for fully processed AC and DC rotating-machine windings rated 750 W or higher. Projects using IEEE practice should refer to the edition of IEEE 43 named in their specification. Do not mix acceptance numbers from different documents without checking scope and temperature correction rules.
A reproducible test record
Before testing, isolate, lock out and prove the machine safe. Follow the motor and test-instrument instructions for discharge and stored charge. The record should include:
| Field | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Motor model and serial number | Ties the result to one winding |
| Winding section and test connection | Shows what was included or isolated |
| Test voltage and instrument | Makes repeat measurements comparable |
| 1-minute and 10-minute readings | Preserves the values behind PI |
| Winding and ambient temperature | IR changes strongly with temperature |
| Relative humidity and machine condition | Helps explain surface leakage and condensation |
| Time since shutdown, cleaning or drying | Separates process changes from deterioration |
| Final discharge confirmation | Documents safe completion |
If RTDs, surge capacitors, cables or electronic accessories remain connected, state that explicitly. Their presence may change the result or restrict the permissible test voltage.
How to read the result
Use three lenses rather than one threshold.
1. Compare with the governing limit. Use the project standard and manufacturer instructions applicable to that insulation system and machine rating.
2. Compare with the machine’s own history. Correct or normalize readings as required by the selected procedure. A stable trend under comparable conditions often says more than a comparison with an unrelated motor.
3. Compare with other evidence. Look for moisture, oil, conductive dust, tracking, heater failure, blocked drains or a recent process upset. If the consequence of failure is high, additional offline diagnostics may be justified.
ABB’s manual for induction motors and generators notes that dirt and humidity tend to reduce both IR and PI. It also cautions that PI may not be meaningful when insulation resistance is already several thousand megohms. That is why a ratio should never replace the underlying readings.
Common interpretation errors
- Comparing a hot post-run reading with a cold workshop reading without applying the chosen procedure.
- Reporting only PI and discarding the 1-minute and 10-minute values.
- Treating IR as a dielectric-strength test.
- Testing through connected cables or accessories without documenting them.
- Energising immediately after a DC test without completing the required discharge.
- Drying a contaminated winding without first identifying whether the contaminant will become more conductive or damage the insulation.
Decision rule
Do not approve energisation from a single untraceable number. Approve when the test followed the selected standard or manufacturer procedure, the conditions are recorded, the result is acceptable on that basis and any adverse trend or physical evidence has been resolved.
Related reading:
